Who did you prefer??

[The Commish]

Its hard for me to choose for two reasons.

One, I hate the character. Not love to hate, just hate.

Number two........I have never seen anyone other than LW play the role for any length of time.

[rhda8386]

Have only seen SJB and LW ... think I prefer SJB. But, pretty much hate Carly no matter who's in the role!

[The Commish]

Aug 26, 2011 19:02:32 GMT -5 rhda8386 said:

Have only seen SJB and LW ... think I prefer SJB. But, pretty much hate Carly no matter who's in the role!

I knew I liked you!!!! LOL

[robertluvsholly]

i prefer the third one-- who was never given a chance LOL

[lakesgirl]

Sarah Brown. I thought she was outstanding in the role. I like Laura Wright okay. I couldn't stand Tamara. There was something just "off" about her to me. She doesn't seem like she's leading lady material to me (although I know a lot of people love her).

[The Commish]

Switching soaps here.


Who did you prefer?

Jack Abbott -- Terry Lester or Peter Bergman?


For me it was Terry Lester. To me, the other guy was always Cliff Warner and an imposter. I quit watching Y & R shortly after the recast.

[rhda8386]

Don't watch Y&R, but *still* think "Cliff" any time I see PB!

[travlingal35]

David Lewis since he originated the role and set the standard.

[mike]

Aug 14, 2011 23:33:16 GMT -5 rhda8386 said:

Aug 12, 2011 18:21:29 GMT -5 The Commish said:

Nope nope you have to choose. Let's say Alan comes back, he has been held by Franco/Helena/Jerry Jax along with AJ. When you picture the scene where they walk into the room to shock Monica, who do you picture as AJ?

Justin Whalen

He made a good Jimmy Olsen on Lois and Clark though !

[mike]

Oh my--don't know if I will catch up with them all but:

Liked both Kurt and Wally as Ned but prefer Ned

David Lewis is the only Edward for me

David Wallace for Tom Hardy

Duke---really ? There is a choice ? It can only be Ian

AJ---I liked both Sean and Billy----Billy was a bit jarring at first due to looking so differently but I think I preferred him in the end.

Carly----well, I stopped watching GH the day that Tamara Braun was gone and they brought in crazy Georgie from OLTL to play the role. So I have never seen much of Laura Wright in the role. When I was DVRing it every day due to Ethan, I fast forwarded anything that had to do with Sonny, Jason and the mob so I wasn't watching anything with Carly either. So to me, I just don't see LW as Carly. It would be pretty much a tie between Sarah and Tamara.

[mrsbig]

GB only had a month worth of scenes compared to Ian's epic 3 years so anyone that chooses him is nutso or w/agenda ;D

David Lewis is genius without even opening his mouth as Edward. Ingle does very little for me after that and is one of the things I wish they'd fix on nuGH.

Didn't see more than one scene of Billy's AJ but Sean was spectacular. Billy is not the best actor overall I think.

LW is bland as Carly. I saw TB in a miscarriage scene and it was brilliant. I've only seen SB as Claudia and she was awesome.

I hope they bring David Wallace back as Tom Hardy. He was so good and I've never understood the big deal about Matt Ashford.

Love GV as adult Lucky (he stands on his own two feet more) and JJ as child/teenage Lucky. JJ's performing to me has changed from when he was younger and there is something that is too intellectual about it. (granted I know very little about acting but it's what I feel)

Kurt McKinney had chemistry with every woman as Ned and I loved his subtlety. Wally is very charming too but I'd have to see an older Kurt to really compare because there is something about him that appeals to me more.

Peter Bergman is Jack Abbott. Terry Lester is not the best looking guy. Sorry and just doesn't seem as powerful.